thanksgivingThe season of gratitude for the bounty of the harvest is upon us, friends, and we here at Short Street Cakes are here to help you celebrate!  We are offering our annual Cakesgiving Cake Sale, with our best-loved cakes available every day without an order and at a discount, as well as introducing our full line of house-made pies.  We are also offering our legendary Thanksgiving Double-Whammy: the Piecake, which is a pie baked inside a cake.  If you order a piecake, YOU WILL NOT BE SORRY.   Click HERE or scroll down for our Thanksgiving holiday Pie, Cake and Piecake menus. We thank you and we love you!


Cakesgiving Cake Sale:

Beginning Saturday, November 23 through Wednesday, November 27th, Short Street Cakes will be offering five of our best-loved flavors of cake at a reduced price and available for pick up without an advance order! Dozens of Medium-Sized (2-layer 8″) Mexican Chocolate, Italian Cream Cake, Strawberry Short Street, Salted Caramel, and Sweet Potato Spice Cakes will be on hand every day during Thanksgiving Week, and they’ll be ON SALE at $28 apiece. Our regular menu will also be available, at regular prices, with the regular minimum two days’ notice.

images (5)

We will also be offering the full menu of our new house-made, hand-made pies.  Place your order 48 hours in advance to be sure you get the flavor of your choosing; otherwise, drop by and see what we have on hand!

($22 per 9” pie)

• Sweet Potato Pie
• Lemon Meringue Pie
• Pumpkin Pie

($24 per 9” pie)

• Double Crust Apple Pie
• Lattice-Top Blueberry or Strawberry Pie
• Old-Fashioned Pecan Pie

($26 per 9” pie)

• Coconut Cream Pie
• Banana Cream Pie
• Chocolate French Silk Pie
• Key Lime Pie

All Mini Pies are $6.00 each.  Minimum of 2 mini pies per order, or just see what we have on hand. As with our cupcakes, we have a daily variety of mini pies available for purchase without an order. As with our cakes, we ask that you order your 9″ pies at least 48 hours in advance, and we offer gluten-free pie crust upon request.  All of our pies are made fresh to order, from-scratch and with love, and represent the very best in the classic tradition of Southern Pies.


And, the moment you’ve all been waiting for: The Piecake!  For more info into the background and history of the piecake, read more here.

The Piecake is available in the following Flavors:

  • Pecan Pie inside Sweet Potato Cake
  • Blueberry Pie inside Lemon Pound Cake
  • Apple Pie inside Vanilla Pound Cake
If you have another flavor combination idea, let us know and we will do our best to make it happen!
Piecakes are available in two sizes:
  • Medium (4″ pie inside a 6″ cake: feeds 10-15) $30
  • Large (9″ pie inside a 10″ cake: feeds 30) $68


Just to be clear: this is a whole pie baked inside a whole cake, people!

Allright, Happy Thanksgiving.  We hope you have a fantastic time eating and drinking with those that you love.  I know we will: we’ll be closed on Thursday, November 28th and Friday, November 29th for the holiday! We’ll be open again for the weekend.  Thanks and love,

Jodi and Short Street Cakes (and Pies)